Tempt with Mayhem
Played in 1,971 Grixis decks
2230+15+4+5+10+16+
Color Identity Spread
Commanders
Parnesse, the Subtle Brush 54.8% of decks
Parnesse, the Subtle Brush 54.8% of decks
The Valeyard 45.7% of decks
The Valeyard 45.7% of decks
Vial Smasher the Fierce // Ludevic, Necro-Alchemist 13.3% of decks
Vial Smasher the Fierce // Ludevic, Necro-Alchemist 13.3% of decks
The Twelfth Doctor // Vislor Turlough 9.6% of decks
The Twelfth Doctor // Vislor Turlough 9.6% of decks
Cormela, Glamour Thief 2.5% of decks
Cormela, Glamour Thief 2.5% of decks
Ludevic, Necro-Alchemist // Sengir, the Dark Baron 20.0% of decks
Ludevic, Necro-Alchemist // Sengir, the Dark Baron 20.0% of decks
Most Relevant
Split Decision 32.1% of decks
Split Decision 32.1% of decks
Prisoner's Dilemma 36.1% of decks
Prisoner's Dilemma 36.1% of decks
Mob Verdict 29.8% of decks
Mob Verdict 29.8% of decks
Truth or Consequences 27.6% of decks
Truth or Consequences 27.6% of decks
Trap the Trespassers 23.8% of decks
Trap the Trespassers 23.8% of decks
Illusion of Choice 24.1% of decks
Illusion of Choice 24.1% of decks
That's every commander.
All commanders (22)
- Parnesse, the Subtle Brush relevance 5.12 · 54.8% (448 of 817 decks)
- The Valeyard relevance 4.97 · 45.7% (483 of 1,057 decks)
- Vial Smasher the Fierce // Ludevic, Necro-Alchemist relevance 2.16 · 13.3% (41 of 308 decks)
- The Twelfth Doctor // Vislor Turlough relevance 1.80 · 9.6% (31 of 324 decks)
- Cormela, Glamour Thief relevance 1.21 · 2.5% (60 of 2,437 decks)
- Ludevic, Necro-Alchemist // Sengir, the Dark Baron relevance 1.17 · 20.0% (5 of 25 decks)
- Sol'Kanar the Tainted relevance 1.02 · 4.7% (12 of 253 decks)
- The Madcap Jester relevance 0.85 · 1.7% (32 of 1,875 decks)
- Anhelo, the Painter relevance 0.83 · 1.4% (47 of 3,409 decks)
- Marchesa, Dealer of Death relevance 0.82 · 1.3% (49 of 3,685 decks)
- Zevlor, Elturel Exile relevance 0.77 · 1.4% (35 of 2,501 decks)
- Silas Renn, Seeker Adept // Krark, the Thumbless relevance 0.71 · 2.5% (10 of 403 decks)
- Jeleva, Nephalia's Scourge relevance 0.69 · 1.4% (23 of 1,634 decks)
- Nicol Bolas relevance 0.68 · 1.8% (14 of 767 decks)
- Vial Smasher the Fierce // Esior, Wardwing Familiar relevance 0.58 · 3.8% (4 of 106 decks)
- Vial Smasher the Fierce // Kraum, Ludevic's Opus relevance 0.56 · 1.9% (8 of 425 decks)
- Vial Smasher the Fierce // Sakashima of a Thousand Faces relevance 0.48 · 1.1% (13 of 1,227 decks)
- The Tenth Doctor // Vislor Turlough relevance 0.33 · 7.7% (1 of 13 decks)
- Silas Renn, Seeker Adept // Jeska, Thrice Reborn relevance 0.21 · 2.6% (1 of 39 decks)
- Kraum, Ludevic's Opus // Tevesh Szat, Doom of Fools relevance 0.20 · 1.1% (2 of 183 decks)
- Ludevic, Necro-Alchemist // Tevesh Szat, Doom of Fools relevance 0.17 · 1.7% (1 of 60 decks)
- Garza Zol, Plague Queen relevance 0.14 · 1.2% (1 of 81 decks)
All most relevant (30)
- Split Decision relevance 1.72 · 32.1% (633 of 1,971 decks)
- Prisoner's Dilemma relevance 1.71 · 36.1% (712 of 1,971 decks)
- Mob Verdict relevance 1.56 · 29.8% (587 of 1,971 decks)
- Truth or Consequences relevance 1.42 · 27.6% (544 of 1,971 decks)
- Trap the Trespassers relevance 1.35 · 23.8% (470 of 1,971 decks)
- Illusion of Choice relevance 1.34 · 24.1% (475 of 1,971 decks)
- Capital Punishment relevance 1.33 · 24.3% (478 of 1,971 decks)
- Tyrant's Choice relevance 1.32 · 24.2% (476 of 1,971 decks)
- Plea for Power relevance 1.31 · 25.1% (495 of 1,971 decks)
- Grudge Keeper relevance 1.25 · 21.3% (420 of 1,971 decks)
- Ensnared by the Mara relevance 1.23 · 36.1% (712 of 1,971 decks)
- Coercive Portal relevance 1.22 · 21.3% (419 of 1,971 decks)
- Double Vision relevance 1.21 · 30.2% (596 of 1,971 decks)
- Sadistic Shell Game relevance 1.21 · 21.1% (416 of 1,971 decks)
- Model of Unity relevance 1.20 · 20.6% (406 of 1,971 decks)
- Bite of the Black Rose relevance 1.19 · 20.6% (407 of 1,971 decks)
- Hunted by The Family relevance 1.09 · 24.5% (483 of 1,971 decks)
- Great Intelligence's Plan relevance 1.07 · 29.7% (586 of 1,971 decks)
- Sycorax Commander relevance 1.04 · 24.5% (483 of 1,971 decks)
- This Is How It Ends relevance 1.02 · 26.2% (516 of 1,971 decks)
- Return the Favor relevance 1.02 · 31.7% (624 of 1,971 decks)
- Expropriate relevance 0.97 · 21.3% (420 of 1,971 decks)
- Cormela, Glamour Thief relevance 0.94 · 28.5% (562 of 1,971 decks)
- Davros, Dalek Creator relevance 0.94 · 24.2% (477 of 1,971 decks)
- Midnight Crusader Shuttle relevance 0.92 · 21.3% (419 of 1,971 decks)
- The Dalek Emperor relevance 0.91 · 22.7% (448 of 1,971 decks)
- Seize the Spotlight relevance 0.90 · 23.8% (469 of 1,971 decks)
- Messenger Jays relevance 0.88 · 13.6% (269 of 1,971 decks)
- Goblin Electromancer relevance 0.86 · 35.2% (693 of 1,971 decks)
- Kess, Dissident Mage relevance 0.84 · 32.4% (639 of 1,971 decks)
All creatures (15)
- Grudge Keeper relevance 1.25 · 21.3% (420 of 1,971 decks)
- Sycorax Commander relevance 1.04 · 24.5% (483 of 1,971 decks)
- Cormela, Glamour Thief relevance 0.94 · 28.5% (562 of 1,971 decks)
- Davros, Dalek Creator relevance 0.94 · 24.2% (477 of 1,971 decks)
- The Dalek Emperor relevance 0.91 · 22.7% (448 of 1,971 decks)
- Messenger Jays relevance 0.88 · 13.6% (269 of 1,971 decks)
- Goblin Electromancer relevance 0.86 · 35.2% (693 of 1,971 decks)
- Kess, Dissident Mage relevance 0.84 · 32.4% (639 of 1,971 decks)
- Missy relevance 0.83 · 20.1% (396 of 1,971 decks)
- Wandering Archaic // Explore the Vastlands relevance 0.79 · 15.1% (297 of 1,971 decks)
- Alania, Divergent Storm relevance 0.77 · 16.7% (329 of 1,971 decks)
- Thunderclap Drake relevance 0.77 · 17.9% (353 of 1,971 decks)
- The Master, Gallifrey's End relevance 0.77 · 17.8% (350 of 1,971 decks)
- Stormcatch Mentor relevance 0.67 · 22.1% (435 of 1,971 decks)
- Storm-Kiln Artist relevance 0.65 · 30.9% (610 of 1,971 decks)
All artifacts (4)
- Coercive Portal relevance 1.22 · 21.3% (419 of 1,971 decks)
- Model of Unity relevance 1.20 · 20.6% (406 of 1,971 decks)
- Midnight Crusader Shuttle relevance 0.92 · 21.3% (419 of 1,971 decks)
- Tempting Contract relevance 0.70 · 12.5% (247 of 1,971 decks)
All enchantments (5)
- Double Vision relevance 1.21 · 30.2% (596 of 1,971 decks)
- Genesis of the Daleks relevance 0.83 · 19.8% (390 of 1,971 decks)
- Arcane Bombardment relevance 0.71 · 17.0% (335 of 1,971 decks)
- Hive Mind relevance 0.68 · 12.8% (253 of 1,971 decks)
- The Toymaker's Trap relevance 0.66 · 12.2% (241 of 1,971 decks)
All instants (10)
- Split Decision relevance 1.72 · 32.1% (633 of 1,971 decks)
- Trap the Trespassers relevance 1.35 · 23.8% (470 of 1,971 decks)
- Illusion of Choice relevance 1.34 · 24.1% (475 of 1,971 decks)
- This Is How It Ends relevance 1.02 · 26.2% (516 of 1,971 decks)
- Return the Favor relevance 1.02 · 31.7% (624 of 1,971 decks)
- Chef's Kiss relevance 0.74 · 12.8% (253 of 1,971 decks)
- Display of Power relevance 0.74 · 15.4% (304 of 1,971 decks)
- Narset's Reversal relevance 0.69 · 27.2% (536 of 1,971 decks)
- Galvanic Iteration relevance 0.69 · 16.8% (331 of 1,971 decks)
- Increasing Vengeance relevance 0.64 · 16.9% (333 of 1,971 decks)
All sorceries (16)
- Prisoner's Dilemma relevance 1.71 · 36.1% (712 of 1,971 decks)
- Mob Verdict relevance 1.56 · 29.8% (587 of 1,971 decks)
- Truth or Consequences relevance 1.42 · 27.6% (544 of 1,971 decks)
- Capital Punishment relevance 1.33 · 24.3% (478 of 1,971 decks)
- Tyrant's Choice relevance 1.32 · 24.2% (476 of 1,971 decks)
- Plea for Power relevance 1.31 · 25.1% (495 of 1,971 decks)
- Ensnared by the Mara relevance 1.23 · 36.1% (712 of 1,971 decks)
- Sadistic Shell Game relevance 1.21 · 21.1% (416 of 1,971 decks)
- Bite of the Black Rose relevance 1.19 · 20.6% (407 of 1,971 decks)
- Hunted by The Family relevance 1.09 · 24.5% (483 of 1,971 decks)
- Great Intelligence's Plan relevance 1.07 · 29.7% (586 of 1,971 decks)
- Expropriate relevance 0.97 · 21.3% (420 of 1,971 decks)
- Seize the Spotlight relevance 0.90 · 23.8% (469 of 1,971 decks)
- Tempt with Reflections relevance 0.79 · 12.8% (252 of 1,971 decks)
- Creative Technique relevance 0.72 · 12.5% (247 of 1,971 decks)
- Choice of Damnations relevance 0.65 · 11.4% (224 of 1,971 decks)
EDH data for Tempt with Mayhem: adoption stats, associated cards, and its most popular commanders, from 1,971 real decks.





























































